Tesla joins S&P 500


January 21, 2021

Image titel:


Tesla joins S&P 500

Graphic representation of Tesla's stock index

It may seem contradictory, since joining an important market index is a very good thing, requiring funds to adjust their holdings. In Tesla’s case, I see at least USD 8 billion would have to be invested through them. I tend to doubt this will automatically lead to a massive increase in valuation. Index funds may already have positions based on a variety of investment vehicles, such as options that can be turned into shares without any relevant influence on the price. Perhaps out of pure contrariness, the stock could turn sour when things are looking their best because analysts, investors and the media see only rising prices, completely ignoring the risks.

Then even Goldman Sachs’ latest move to raise the price target to USD 780 can’t rock my boat. But my point is wholly another. There have been a slew of companies that joined a major index only to see their stock fall, not rise – despite high expectations. It may well be that Tesla and its shareholder community’s prayers have been answered, but that’s not a guarantee shares will rise. Buy the rumor – sell the fact. Also, the amount of short interest, 45 million shares, is downright ludicrous, a mere 6.2 percent of the free float. And it’s even less when you calculate Tesla’s total stock, including CEO Elon Musk’s, coming to well over 1 billion shares, after the five-for-one split.


Fans had hoped Tesla’s entry into the index would trigger a short squeeze, pressing short sellers into covering their positions, causing a price surge. However, shares are already at an all-time high of around USD 650, bringing Tesla’s market cap to over USD 580 billion. Where will it end? Shouldn’t Tesla first deliver convincing financials, i.e., sustainable high profits?

Analysts at odds

While Goldman Sachs set a new USD 780 target price, analysts are arguing about where the stock will go after witnessing the 2020 hike from around USD 300 to USD 3,800 (non-adjusted for the stock split). With a share price in the neighborhood of USD 460, several people thought of as insiders started selling stock. Tesla’s chief financial officer gave up 1,250 of 19,000 shares, some directors sold between 1,000 and 5,000 – one even 155,000. You could argue these are negligible amounts, but the number of leading employees cashing in are not. As far as I know, there are no inside buyers. Meanwhile, J.P. Morgan analyst Ryan Brinkman raised his target price from USD 80 to USD 90, saying “Tesla’s valuation is difficult to conceive in any imagined scenario.”

With a profit of USD 0.76 instead of USD 0.60 a share, third-quarter non-GAAP results were better than predicted. The more conservative GAAP figures looked altogether different. Analysts forecast USD 0.50 earnings per share, but the actual EPS came to USD 0.27. Revenue was USD 8.8 billion, about USD 500 million higher than projected. Cash and cash equivalents improved to more than USD 14 billion due to a USD 5 billion capital raise. What may look like a healthy cushion is not all that fat considering investment plans of over USD 10 billion, plus the multi-billions in debts and obligations.

Net income was USD 331 million, thanks to USD 397 million in regulatory credit sales. In the last three quarters, the credits allowed Tesla to post revenues to the tune of USD 1.2 billion. Windfalls, you could say, that have little to do with business operations.

Some analysts see the stock rising further. Others, like Citibank and J.P. Morgan, are rather at USD 120 and USD 90. I hover in the middle at USD 250 to USD 350 when it comes to my expectations of 2021. Which is good for fuel cells and hydrogen, although Tesla and the analysts, too, are ignoring that. Let Tesla build the world’s largest battery factory in Grünheide, supported with EUR 3 billion to EUR 5 billion in government funds, including the European Union’s share, and let Elon Musk announce he could very well imagine working with an established automaker. I allow myself to be skeptical. Meanwhile, Tesla [Nasdaq: TSLA] seized the day once more, as an ATM program is expected to generate another USD 5 billion for the electric car manufacturer, the second USD 5 billion within just a few weeks. Wonderfully euphoric. But things could get grim when Tesla disappoints. I’ve been expecting that for some time.

Risk warning

Share trading can result in a total loss of your investment. Consider spreading the risk as a sensible precaution. The fuel cell companies mentioned in this article are small- and mid-cap businesses, which means their stocks may experience high volatility. The information in this article is based on publicly available sources, and the views and opinions expressed herein are those of the author only. They are not to be taken as a suggestion of what stocks to buy or sell and come without any explicit or implicit guarantee or warranty. The author focuses on mid-term and long-term prospects, not short-term gains, and may own shares in the company or the companies being analyzed.

Author: Sven Jösting, written December 18th, 2020

Kategorien: Germany

Here are interesting and current articles on the topic of hydrogen – stocks and the stock market!

Economic prospects for companies in the hydrogen sector | Future, stocks & hydrogen companies on the stock exchange and more…

Which hydrogen companies will prevail in the competitive market in the long term? Get tips and cartwheels and learn more about risks or opportunities. Our stock market specialist and expert author Sven Jösting reports critically, independently and competently.

Jun 13 2024

H2 Bank Selects Seven Projects”

The European Commission is allocating nearly 720 million euros to seven projects for renewable...
Jun 13 2024

World’s one-of-a-kind H2 test lab

Electrolyzers on the test bench In Hydrogen Lab Bremerhaven, manufacturers and operators of...
Jun 13 2024

First commercial green hydrogen production

Solar Global operates electrolyzer plant in Czech Republic An electrolyzer in the town of...
Jun 12 2024

Hydrogen 3.0

“Are we on the cusp of a hydrogen revolution or merely witnessing the build-up of another bubble?”...
Jun 12 2024

Mechatronic H2 pressure regulator

Up until now, Italian company Landi Renzo has been mainly known for its conversion sets for gas...
Jun 11 2024

Establishment of a metrological infrastructure

Flow measurement of high-pressure gas and liquid hydrogen In the field of flow measurement, the...
Jun 11 2024

FRHY Stack, first of its kind!

Technology platform for high-rate electrolyzer production The cooperative FRHY project, which...
Jun 10 2024

HySupply – German-Australian hydrogen bridge

Acatech and BDI show what’s feasible Defossilizing the energy system is an important goal of the...
Jun 05 2024

In the beginning was the refueling station

Creating planning security through the development of H2 infrastructure We have long discussed the...
Jun 04 2024

Digital potential

Low-cost green hydrogen through digitalization Plans to expand Germany’s hydrogen landscape are...
Jun 04 2024

A new energy infrastructure is emerging

“Green” and “blue” ammonia from other continents to come to Europe Ammonia produced from...
May 31 2024

Fuel cell systems for grid hardening

Interview with Christian Leu and Benedikt Eska from Axiosus An important but often neglected area...
May 30 2024

A new energy infrastructure is emerging

“Green” and “blue” ammonia from other continents to come to Europe Ammonia produced from...
May 16 2024

New CFO for H-Tec Systems

Electrolyzer manufacturer H-Tec Systems underwent restructuring at the turn of the year and...
May 16 2024

One-man show continues to grow

Hydrogeit Verlag celebrates its 20th anniversary The Hydrogeit Verlag publishing house has been...
May 15 2024

Hydrogen for the post-coal era

Nuclear energy also to power electrolysis in Hungary In May 2021, Hungary published its national...
May 15 2024

Hüwener to lead OGE

Thomas Hüwener will become the new management spokesman for transmission system operator OGE from...
May 15 2024

Accelerating expansion and reducing hurdles

German government adopts power plant strategy It took a long time, but now it's here – the power...
May 15 2024

Brussels approves IPCEI projects

3rd funding wave for H2 infrastructure measures The decision has finally come. In mid-February...
May 15 2024

Apex becomes H2APEX

Apex, headquartered in Rostock, Germany, is continuing to make big strides forward in the hydrogen...


Leave a Reply