How Feasible Is a Zero-Carbon Steel Industry?


September 3, 2018

Image titel:


How Feasible Is a Zero-Carbon Steel Industry?


ArcelorMittal’s direct reduction plant, © M. Hölling

Considering the highly ambitious GHG reduction targets that both the German government and the European Union have announced for 2050, it seems hardly enough to transform only the electric power market. Each part of the economy must see dramatic changes if the goal is a zero-carbon future. This also includes the steel industry, which produces around 6 percent of the carbon dioxide emissions in Germany and will need to respond to great challenges to survive within the EU. One option to reduce its carbon footprint is the use of renewably generated hydrogen and electricity. While technically feasible today, such alternative methods of production would come at great cost that no steelworks could bear without some government assistance.

Traditional steelmaking

Top-quality steel, which is needed, for example, to manufacture auto parts, is produced from ores that are rich in iron oxides. Their high purity is the only way to ensure lightweight, high-strength products. Today, most steel is made by burning coke in a blast furnace. Despite being highly efficient, this process releases more than a ton of carbon dioxide for every ton of steel produced. Already, there are techniques that can achieve the same goal based on a hydrogen-rich blend. One of them is direct reduction, employed by companies such as ArcelorMittal Hamburg. It substitutes natural gas for coke and creates, inside a steam reformer, a reducing gas that contains about 60 percent hydrogen.

In partnership with ArcelorMittal Hamburg, the HAW – Hamburg University of Applied Sciences has studied the effects of using pure hydrogen, produced by a power-to-gas system, for the direct reduction of iron ore (see fig. 1). This approach will result in a zero-carbon process provided renewable electricity is fed into the installation. The gas will subsequently be mixed with re-cycled hydrogen and heated to about 900 °C, the temperature required for the relevant chemical reaction to occur.


Simulations have shown that one ton of H2BI will need around 635 normal cubic meters of hydrogen. If the aim is to produce 1 million tons a year, demand will amount to 80,000 normal cubic meters per hour. At 75 percent electrical efficiency, the power-to-gas system will therefore have to provide 375 megawatts. This figure is much higher than the individual capacity of today’s systems, which typically range from 1 megawatt to 6 megawatts.

The steel industry’s dilemma

The steel industry faces the same problem that the energy sector had around 20 years ago. Companies have innovative, and sustainable, ideas and plans, but there is no incentive to implement them in the current business environment. The following is hoped to explain why that is the case.

One important reason is the cost of electricity. The least expensive renewable resource to produce hydrogen is onshore wind, for which around EUR 80 is paid per megawatt-hour via the German Renewable Energy Sources Act. There also need to be guarantees that the H2BI plant will run for a good portion of the year. Overall, EUR 100 per megawatt-hour of electricity seems like a reasonable assumption to make. Thus, operating expenses will be about EUR 37,500 per hour, or EUR 300 per ton of H2BI. In comparison, iron reduction by conventional means costs about EUR 40, or one-seventh, per ton, which shows that the new process is far from economically viable at this point. The margins in the steel industry are too low to compensate, so that zero-carbon reduction would produce nothing but losses.

Capital expenditure also needs to be part of the calculation. A similar but conventional direct reduction plant to produce 1 million tons of steel a year requires around EUR 300 million. At an H2BI plant, the electrolyzers alone would come to about EUR 3 million for each megawatt of capacity and a total of EUR 1.12 billion. Here, too, it is quite clear that the new technology cannot compete in the current market environment.

Another option would be to introduce a carbon tariff, a tax to reflect the carbon footprint of each steel product on the EU market. This tariff could lead to hydrogen steelmaking becoming economically viable. Considering free trade and globalization, however, it seems as unlikely to succeed as the other two.


From a technical point of view, renewably sourced hydrogen could help the steel industry create new and eco-friendlier products with a lower carbon footprint. While simulating one method to produce the hydrogen and evaluating the results, it has been determined that although the production is technically feasible, it needs to become much less expensive to be truly competitive and attract investors. To create a more favorable market environment, government policy needs to change.

Written by Prof. Dr.-Ing. Marc Hölling, Hochschule für Angewandte Wissenschaften (HAW) Hamburg, Germany

Kategorien: Europe | Germany

Here are interesting and current articles on the topic of hydrogen – stocks and the stock market!

Economic prospects for companies in the hydrogen sector | Future, stocks & hydrogen companies on the stock exchange and more…

Which hydrogen companies will prevail in the competitive market in the long term? Get tips and cartwheels and learn more about risks or opportunities. Our stock market specialist and expert author Sven Jösting reports critically, independently and competently.

Jul 15 2024

Only a third of NIP projects approved

Interview with Elena Hof, Paul Karzel and Jörg Starr from CEP The Clean Energy Partnership or CEP...
Jul 15 2024

Switzerland’s largest H2 plant

Energy group Axpo and the company Rhiienergie have launched the first H2 production plant for...
Jul 15 2024

Why hydrogen stocks can fall even further

Max Deml’s stock analysis In the past, hydrogen was usually isolated from fossil fuels such as...
Jun 13 2024

H2 Bank Selects Seven Projects”

The European Commission is allocating nearly 720 million euros to seven projects for renewable...
Jun 13 2024

World’s one-of-a-kind H2 test lab

Electrolyzers on the test bench In Hydrogen Lab Bremerhaven, manufacturers and operators of...
Jun 13 2024

First commercial green hydrogen production

Solar Global operates electrolyzer plant in Czech Republic An electrolyzer in the town of...
Jun 12 2024

Hydrogen 3.0

“Are we on the cusp of a hydrogen revolution or merely witnessing the build-up of another bubble?”...
Jun 12 2024

Mechatronic H2 pressure regulator

Up until now, Italian company Landi Renzo has been mainly known for its conversion sets for gas...
Jun 11 2024

Establishment of a metrological infrastructure

Flow measurement of high-pressure gas and liquid hydrogen In the field of flow measurement, the...
Jun 11 2024

FRHY Stack, first of its kind!

Technology platform for high-rate electrolyzer production The cooperative FRHY project, which...
Jun 10 2024

HySupply – German-Australian hydrogen bridge

Acatech and BDI show what’s feasible Defossilizing the energy system is an important goal of the...
Jun 05 2024

In the beginning was the refueling station

Creating planning security through the development of H2 infrastructure We have long discussed the...
Jun 04 2024

Digital potential

Low-cost green hydrogen through digitalization Plans to expand Germany’s hydrogen landscape are...
Jun 04 2024

A new energy infrastructure is emerging

“Green” and “blue” ammonia from other continents to come to Europe Ammonia produced from...
May 31 2024

Fuel cell systems for grid hardening

Interview with Christian Leu and Benedikt Eska from Axiosus An important but often neglected area...
May 30 2024

A new energy infrastructure is emerging

“Green” and “blue” ammonia from other continents to come to Europe Ammonia produced from...
May 16 2024

New CFO for H-Tec Systems

Electrolyzer manufacturer H-Tec Systems underwent restructuring at the turn of the year and...
May 16 2024

One-man show continues to grow

Hydrogeit Verlag celebrates its 20th anniversary The Hydrogeit Verlag publishing house has been...
May 15 2024

Hydrogen for the post-coal era

Nuclear energy also to power electrolysis in Hungary In May 2021, Hungary published its national...
May 15 2024

Hüwener to lead OGE

Thomas Hüwener will become the new management spokesman for transmission system operator OGE from...

1 Comment

  1. Amanda

    Innovative solutions in most areas are really not heavily incentivized. If it doesn’t align with the private sector’s agenda, it’s near impossible to get proper funding. Zero carbon will dampen profit.



  1. GrInHy – Sunfire Tests RSOC in Salzgitter › H2-international - […] ArcelorMittal (see How Feasible Is a Zero-Carbon Steel Industry?), Salzgitter Flachstahl employs a direct reduction process. The medium-term goal…
  2. Is Joe Biden taking climate change seriously? - Global News 24 Hours - […] or agriculture. Unlike electricity production, there are no zero-carbon replacement processes for steel, concrete, or farming that are already…
  3. In a war on weather modify, The united states can have solar panels and butter - SupreMeuk - […] speedily — like carbon capture, state-of-the-art nuclear styles, subsequent-era recycling, zero-carbon metal and concrete, and so […]

Leave a Reply

Discover more from H2-international

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading